Transportation Costs Examined at Phoenixville School Board Budget Meeting
The PASD budget was knocked down to include a 3.89 percent tax increase.
Editor's Note: Due to the length of the meeting, this will be broken up into two parts. Watch for a second story on the budget meeting on Phoenixville Patch.
Reducing legal fees, the payment to the Phoenixville Community Education Foundation and factoring in a reduction in audit costs and savings from bond refinancing, Phoenixville Area School District’s proposed tax increase now stands at 3.89 percent.
That’s down from the 5.08 percent included in the preliminary budget, and most likely that number will fluctuate with other savings. There’s also the unknown of school funding in the governor’s budget, which Gov. Tom Corbett will present Feb. 7.
At a public budget workshop on Tuesday, the board got a closer look at the transportation, technology, professional services and activities and athletics budgets proposed for the 2012-2013 school year.
Stan Johnson, executive director of operations, presented on the transportation budget and some proposed cuts and possible considerations. He hopes to trim $200,000, which should push the tax increase further down. Last year, Johnson and his team worked to reroute buses, switch up bus stops and find other efficiencies to help the district save money. In the preliminary budget, $3.7 million is budgeted for transportation, but Johnson hopes to whittle that to $3.5 million.
The district transports 3,976 students, with 3,944 taking Wolfington buses and 32 students using other services. The 32 students are early intervention, special education and private school students.
“We do try to collaborate with other districts [for those routes],” Johnson said.
The bus routes and stops for 2012-2013 most likely won’t change much, he said, as the district took a good look at creating efficiencies last year. He presented several ideas for saving money on transportation costs. These are all still in the early stages and nothing is set in stone yet. The ideas included:
- Evaluate bus aides: Each bus aide costs the district $17,000, Johnson told the board. Most aides are on board due to behavior issues on the bus, and the district currently uses 18 bus aides. Johnson said he and his team will take a closer look to see if all of those aides are needed or if situations have changed on buses.
- Evaluate mid-day busing for kindergarten students: Johnson said he would not recommend this move, noting that a very small number of kindergarten parents drive their kids to and from school, so it would be a big adjustment. It would save the district $72,000. This was put on the “red” list as something the district would only do in dire circumstances.
- Look at PDE reimbursement: The district may not be maxing out its reimbursement from the state’s department of education, Johnson said. Those numbers depend on the age of the bus fleet and other factors.
- Advertise inside school buses: The law is clear on advertising on the outside of buses—you can’t do it. Advertising on the inside, however, may be a possibility. Superintendent Dr. Alan Fegley said it’s more of a school policy issue because it would have to fit into the district’s current advertising rules. Johnson said it may not be an option for the 2012-2013 budget but could work in the future.
- Increase walking distances: The law currently requires that elementary students walk no more than 1½ miles to school while secondary students can walk up to two miles to school. The district’s current policy says that elementary students can walk up to a mile, while secondary students can walk up to 1½ miles. Johnson said he could plug the numbers into a software program to see if changing the district’s policy to be in line with the law would help eliminate any routes. One bus costs the district approximately $40,000.
- Use a common schedule: When the district’s calendar doesn’t line up with the Chester County Intermediate Unit’s calendar or the calendars of other schools, that can mean added transportation expenses. Johnson said the district’s calendar for next year is already aligned pretty closely but he put it on the list of things to consider.
- Pay parents to transport children: The law allows districts to reimburse parents for transporting their children to school at the IRS rates. Big buses wouldn’t be looked at for this initiative, but if the district could save a van run or a smaller bus, paying the parents to bring kids to school might be cheaper than paying for busing, Johnson said.
- Look into hybrid/green vehicles: Wolfington, the district’s main transportation contractor, is currently doing a pilot program with one electric bus through a grant program. Johnson said he’ll be looking closely at potential savings, and he explained that the district could encourage Wolfington to look into more hybrid or electric vehicles if it shows a cost savings. The electric vehicles can only be used for short routes currently, and Johnson said the entire fleet wouldn’t be electric anytime soon, but it could be a savings if the cost of electricity is right.
- Examine the possibility of SEPTA transportation: Board Member Irfan Khan brought this up, and Johnson said there are only two SEPTA routes that currently run through the district and neither come near schools. He said, however, that he’d look into this as a possibility and will follow up with SEPTA.
- Campaign to get parents and students to opt out of busing: The board discussed the possibility of giving students a chance to give up their seats on the bus. This could potentially save bus routes. Students who drive to school could possibly be incentivized to pass up a bus seat if they are offered lower parking fees, which are currently $25 per year. The district will have 120 to 130 parking spaces next year.
Johnson said he felt comfortable reducing the preliminary transportation budget by $200,000 for 2012-2013. Those numbers were not factored into the potential tax increase yet, and by the end of the meeting the tax increase stood at 3.89 percent.
Watch Phoenixville Patch for a follow-up story on the other budgets presented at Tuesday night’s meeting.
The next budget meeting is scheduled for Feb. 21. For a list of topics that will be discussed, see the attached PDF.
birdfan
3:55 pm on Friday, January 27, 2012
if parents taught their children "respect" in the first place you would not need aides on buses.
WE have to pay taxes to pay aides becuase kids are raised thinking that mouthing off and being routy and distructive, and disruptive is funny and cool. No disipline at home means no respect for drivers, teachers, family or each other. The problem starts at home !!!
CNH128
5:15 pm on Friday, January 27, 2012
Agree w/ birdfan - the district shouldn't have to pay for bus aides to control undisciplined kids. If they can't behave on the bus, they should lose the privilege.
John Colarusso
9:28 am on Saturday, January 28, 2012
I also agree w/birdfan. Theses discipline issues are costing taxpayers $17,000 per bus this is crazy. I would put all students and parents on notice that discipline issues of any sort on a bus will not be tolerated, for the safety of others and the pocket of the taxpayer. If there is an issue all involved loose their privileges.why is it not just that simple?
Deb Johnston
11:04 am on Saturday, January 28, 2012
Max out the kids who can walk to school, especially in the borough. My daughter was a walker to Barkley until 3rd or 4th grade in 2001 when she was converted to a bus rider. We live maybe 1/2 mile from Barkley, hmmm. Unfortunately in East Pikeland and Schuylkill Twps there are few sidewalks which is a standing reason why kids "can't" walk to school. Too bad. Encourage bike riding by providing secure bike parking facilities at schools. My kids, juniors at PAHS walk and my daughter especially likes it that she can be in bed until 7 and leave for school 7:20 and be on time where her bus rider friends have to get up sooooo much earlier!
M
12:43 pm on Sunday, January 29, 2012
Ok let's be real...sometimes bus aides are employed for children with special needs and not for the rowdy, undisciplined kids. It is so easy to point fingers at everyone.
Has there been talks of freezing administration/teacher wages for a one-year period? This inevitably could save millions. How about all day kindergarten? This would reduce on mid-day bussing?
We have to at long range solutions not just quick fixes. It amazes me that each time a teacher completes graduate curses they get pay increases. Please tell me when this happens in the "real-world".
Mr.Qchanga
8:57 pm on Thursday, March 8, 2012
The bus aid is a low paying position done by people who care about children. For the at risk kids, these are the first adults that actually get up in the morning to see them. Other notable "adult figures" are either chuggin anti-depressants and going to the trainer, or passed out on the couch with pop tart crust hanging off their lips. So I'm thinking the bus aid is a needed position.
CNH128
8:12 am on Friday, March 9, 2012
Thanks for clearing that up, Qchanga. Really useful. I hadn't realized the scope of how many kids have passed-out, medicated, poptart-encrusted parents.
Mr.Qchanga
8:59 am on Friday, March 9, 2012
CNH128 Its not the Brady Bunch hour at every breakfast table. Immoral is moral and illegal becomes legal. Talk to any loss prevention specialist and they will have countless stories of adults concealing stolen goods in their kids clothing. Those people arent getting up early to make lunches. No they are not.
CNH128
11:16 am on Friday, March 9, 2012
Maybe not. But you haven't provided a good reason for the rest of the Brady Bunch and their taxes to pay for the bus aides.