Kampf Says Voter ID Law Could Increase Turnout

The state Rep. defended the controversial law at a town hall meeting in Phoenixville this week.

With a constitutional challenge to the law raging in Harrisburg, state Rep. Warren Kampf (R-157) suggested that HB 934—the controversial law that blocks citizens without state-issued ID from voting—won’t interfere with the ability of Pennsylvanians to cast their ballots this November and, contrary to conventional wisdom, might actually boost turnout in the state.

“Georgia has a very similar law. They’ve had it for six years. And they had it in 2008 and in those communities which often are said to have been impacted by voter ID laws, the turnout was actually far greater than it should have been demographically," Kampf said at the conclusion of at .

"There isn’t a demonstrated situation where these sorts of laws have disenfranchised people," he added. "And, honestly, I’m beginning to feel like this law may actually enfranchise people. [Though] I can’t guarantee that.” 

Kampf’s are minority views. The Pennsylvania Department of State says that nearly 759,000 registered voters in PA don’t possess a state-issued ID—though they admit that 167,000 of these voters haven’t actually cast a ballot in the past five years—while a University of Washington political science professor, according to CBS News, wrote a paper in July estimating that as many as 757,000 Pennsylvanians who voted in 2008 don’t have the necessary ID to do so this time around.

Kampf emphasized that the state has gone to lengths to ensure the law won't depress turnout. In addition to a robust campaign informing residents about the law, he said ID cards are free for those who can’t afford them and, in response to concerns raised about seniors who have lost their social security card or birth certificate being turned down by PennDOT, said those requirements have been waived effective in August. He added that those who show up at the polls on election day without an ID can cast a provisional ballot, then fax in the necessary forms.

"I want to assist anybody who needs help [getting ID] anywhere in this state," Kampf said.

Opponents of the law have countered that this won’t be enough, and the inconvenience of obtaining an ID will keep many home on election day. They argue that a majority of those without IDs are Democratic voters and that the law is simply a clever effort on the part of state Republicans to suppress voter turnout for political gain. Furthermore, they say, voter fraud in Pennsylvania is a non-problem; an argument that gained additional credibility when the state conceded it has no evidence that such a crime has ever been committed in PA.

While acknowledging that “there is a lot of politics surrounding this voter ID law, probably on both sides,” Kampf suggested that these objections miss the point. He argued that voting is sacrosanct and regardless of the frequency of fraud (he admitted the country doesn’t have a “wide history” of the crime) it makes sense to pass laws that protect against it.

“It never made sense to me when I walked into a polling place…and all I had to do was say my name and sign a signature that was right there in front of me and I could vote. That didn’t seem to me to be a very strong protection,” the representative said.

"I say, gosh, the legislature tried to do something that, absent a crisis, prevented us from getting into a crisis or tried to ensure the credibility of the vote. That can’t be all bad.”

Chris Dyer August 03, 2012 at 11:03 AM
I wasnt trying to change the point of the conversation - I was merely pointing out to everyone that you make these outlandish comments yet are too much of a coward to use your name. It certainly is easy to hide behind a veil when throwing out blanket false statements because theres no way to hold you accountable. So why should we listen to anything that you have to say?
. August 03, 2012 at 11:28 AM
Let me translate Chris Dyer's last comment - "My right wing peers and I have no answer to any of the facts your presented so instead of having a real debate we willl just call you a coward and other names to change the subject". Chris - I could care less if you "listen to anything I have to say". Sorry the truth "hurtz"!
Chris Dyer August 03, 2012 at 11:37 AM
You havent presented any facts, merely repeated talking points that you were spoon fed. But hey, you're up before 11am, so congrats, its a start, maybe today you will become a contributing member of society....maybe, but I kinda have my doubts
Henk August 04, 2012 at 01:06 AM
You tried to describe why the bill is bad, but I did not understand your reasoning. First let me start with noticing that voter fraud does occur, and if you are not familiar with that, please check the internet. Next would be a question: How much voter fraud is acceptable to you? Do you consider the right to vote important enough that actually some effort may be necessary on your part to insure that every eligible vote should be counted and not be erased by voter fraud? Some of the other comments: (1) Absentee ballots: An absentee ballot is actually sent to the address of the registered voter and has the name of the voter on the return envelope. If the person also votes at the poll, the absentee vote will be discarded. Besides, who should the ID be shown to when you receive the absentee ballot in the mail, and you return the ballot by mail? (2) Your sister's maiden name: You will need to keep your records up-to-date, and that is a personal responsibility, nobody can help her with that. (3) Your Mom: You may want to check with your Department of Moter Vehicles and ask them if they have a non-driver ID, they do in Florida. (4) names do not match: It is everyone's responsibility to know their own name and be consistent how you want to be know on official documentation. You should not change or omit parts of your identity. Live is not easy, and then the government makes you get an ID. From a patriotic perspective, I am sorry, but it garantees our freedom.
Henk August 04, 2012 at 01:13 AM
Cynthia, please become familiar with the web site TrueTheVote.org and you will read that voter participation has actually increased in the case of Georgia.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »